I'm Canadian, eh... or is it aye?
This past couple weeks have been overtaken by the life-crowding debacle of the post-9/11 visa application process, and quite frankly there have been moments where it looked like we might not pull this Scottish relocation off. Even now we are waiting for some crucial documents to come in a timely manner so that we can get our applications in and processed as needed. You might have picked up on this in my agonized "poetry" a couple posts back, but we're at this point feeling like we won't believe we're going until we get on the plane.
Regardless, I do allow myself a few rare opportunities to "dream" of the Aberdeen move, and one thing I did recently was download some BBC Scotland podcasts to get a feel for the day-to-day culture. And the first one I listened to was most remarkable for the fact that I only understood about 75% of it! I actually had a dream a while back that my boys came home from their first day of school upset because they didn't know what the teacher was saying.
Overstating it, I hope, but there is going to be culture shock and language issues, even in this English to English move. This is often the first thing people talk about when they hear we are trying to move to Scotland: "Oh your boys are going to pick up the most wonderful accents!" Yup, probably. But its led me to thinking: What will become of my Canadian accent, and even my patriotism?
I read an article recently which said that a "study" showed that people who move to a new country pick up the new language and/or accent more or less quickly relative to the amount of attachment or even pride that they have to their old country.
This is intriguing to me, because knowing myself I have a feeling I'll adapt somewhat. Not because I want to be "cool" in Scotland, but because I just will usually be drawn into talking the language of those around me.
In France last spring I instinctly and consciously (and badly, just ask my wife!) started trying to speak French. I would step up at Starbucks and order in "French" and when they'd respond to me in English I'd realize I had a ways to go. But it just felt right to try, and I enjoyed it, though it gave me a headache sometimes. I got hooked, actually. I was still saying "Merci beaucuoup" the whole flight home, and only stopped when my wife pointed out to me that we had an all-American flight crew.
I tend to think that I'll come home more proud of Canada than I am now. The whole absence-makes-the-heart-grow-fonder kind of thing. I'm not worried about that. To me it isn't an either/or between cultures. You can love, and hope to love, more than one place. Maybe this is my spin on it, but I just know that I tend to join my community. I don't think I lose my identity, per se, or change who I am, but I do start to talk like those I'm with.
But here's my question to you, to get my mind off of the paralyzing pins and needles of the visa-waiting game: If my family does indeed move, and I start "speaking Scottish" somewhat, does that make me a bad Canadian? Feel free to be flippant or fun or philosophical about it. I'm facing some cultural anxiety over it, and am curious what you think.

13 comments:
if you start 'speaking scottish' don't even bother coming back, you would be the worst canadian ever...and i would punch you. very very hard. right in the neck.
in the neck?!!
in the neck.
i hope you come back with a wonderful scottish brogue (sp) and the ability to play the bagpipes and your own set of bagpipes! Don't forget, if it wasn't for Scotland you would have never been born lad! Stu.
I don't think you can lose on this one.
I met a Scottish girl at a party last year. I'd never had trouble with accents much before. To my embarrassment I had to wait a couple seconds after every time she'd finished talking so I could replay what I'd heard in my head and try to make sense of it, before responding. She'd be staring, probably wondering, "what is taking this boy so long?" 5 full seconds between the end of her sentence and the beginning of mine.
It was intimidating.
Just don't ever give up hockey. You can like "football" all you want, but if you ever let the beautiful game replace Canada's game, then you better start swimming for Norway. Have fun. My wife's maiden name is Goodall, so I have all the justification I need to do post-grad work in the Kirk. Maybe Edinburgh with Paul Nimmo?
Nathan: If Mr Miagi taught me anything, the neck jab will never land, my friend.
Stu: I'm not sure you want to give the nation of Scotland that much credit for my birth.
Matthew: Yeah. Intimidating. Exactly. "what is taking this boy so long?" That's funny.
Bradley: You are obsessed with Nimmo, aren't you? Edinburgh looks gorgeous. Don't wait. Come for 2011!
And by the way, football overtook hockey for me a long long time ago, and that has nothing to do with Scotland, just the use of pure unadulterated reason. Being Canadian doesn't mean I have to love hockey any more than it means I have to think highly of Donald S. Cherry, whom, incidentally, I will be calling to see if I can borrow a high-collared shirt or two for next time I see Nathan.
You shouldn't worry about losing your "Canadaisms" because in reality you are not much of a Canadian currently!
You (and I) have abandoned the "Canadaism" of believing that hockey is superior to other sports. That is one major strike against you.
You also call soccer, football. That is a second denial of your Canadian heritage.
Third, you conduct yourself in a gruff manner that goes against the pleasent demeanour that Canadians are supposed to have.
Alson, you are opionated rather than open minded.
And finally your reluctant and sparing use of mayonaise goes against the Canadaism of viewing mayonaise as the second best condiment, second only to maple syrup.
Jon, don't worry about losing your Canadian identity, it has been gone for awhile.
Terry.
In the neck. Funniest blog comment of 2009.
You'll be fine, you're Scottish. And you're not a bad Canadian but you're not an overly patriotic one either so you might turn Scottish in the end.
And Hockey is the best sport in the world, on that your opinion is wrong, morally and reasonably.
Yes, mayonaise!
Tanti: Morally?
If that were so it would not have produced the Donald.
interesting reponses lad Coutts. Remember if it ain't Scottish it's crap. Stewart Randall Coutts.
I didn't pick up the Scottish accent but I did change the words I used. Diary for calendar, flat for apartment, vest for onesie. But if you do pick up the accent, that's great! Doesn't make you less Canadian.
After 6 years as an expat, I definitely look at the US differently--you just get such a different vantage point and exposure to other ways of doing things. But I still have a pride in being American--and a sense of home while I'm there. I'll always be an American first and foremost.
PS. Sorry about the visa hassles. All that logistical stuff is such a pain.
Post a Comment